Degrees of Consciousness, Part 3

Degrees of Consciousness, Part 3

“Consciousness is the water we swim in, and in our everyday lives we have almost as little distance on it as fish do of the sea. We can’t ever climb out of the water and stand on its shore.” [1]

Michael Pollan

The four degrees of consciousness presented by Michael Pollan in his book, “A World Appears,” are sentience, feeling, thought, and a sense of self. If we have the ability to sense, feel, think, and have an awareness of doing so, we possess the elements of human consciousness. And we can learn to elevate those abilities to where we sense, feel, and think ever more deeply and comprehensively about the world around us. We can ponder ourselves as unique, individual creations and marvel at the wonder of the various aspects of creation and our acutely personal awareness of its beauty, mundaneness, and sometimes horror. All of that is wonderful as far as it goes, but as our abilities to sense, feel, think, and be aware increase, we also tend to feel separated because others are not experiencing what we experience in our expanded awareness. We cannot put our experiences into words that others can follow, so it can feel lonely. One must wonder if today’s loneliness epidemic is not a direct result of our increasingly easy access to information and virtual friends and colleagues via social media and AI.

But do any of those abilities represent a more highly evolved consciousness? Is loneliness what we have to look forward to in higher degrees of consciousness? To an extent and for a time, I believe that is true. Those who have heightened sensitivities to light, sound, smell, taste, and touch feel alone and bothered in environments that seem normal to the rest of us. Those with ultra-sensitive feelings may cry or feel embarrassed or ashamed at seemingly innocuous words and actions that go unnoticed by the rest of us. They feel separated from us by the feelings we do not share. In fields of intellectualism, as in academia, those who possess knowledge well beyond what most of the population has any interest in knowing find themselves with only a handful of peers sharing similar passions, most of whom tend to be far away geographically.

What makes these instances of heightened conscious abilities painful and isolating is the sense of separation they seemingly create. In other words, when we are not well-connected with others whose awareness is similar to ours we feel different, weird, and maybe even defective. And it is not just how we feel but also how some in society treat us, not to mention how structures in the world around us may not accommodate the individual needs and preferences we develop as we mature into expanded awareness.

To truly reach higher levels of conscious awareness without the accompanying loneliness we must first learn to direct the four degrees of consciousness toward the intimate interconnectedness of everything in creation and our place within it. Being different, weird, or seemingly defective are only waypoints on a single continuum of normalcy. There is only one reality; we are all in it; and we all belong in it. Not only that, we are necessary to it – just as and where we are. We are individual expressions, yes, but we are individualized expressions of a unified, universal Life in which we live and move and have our being. Whenever our heightened awareness appears to make us better, worse, more or less important than others, our awareness needs to be expanded to show how and where we and others fit together as co-equals in the one Life. This is seldom obvious and might require a degree of faith at first, but the connections are there, and we will find them if we persist.

One question is whether human consciousness, which is inclusive of all four commonly accepted degrees of consciousness, is the highest degree of consciousness attainable. For me, the answer is no. And the answer is no for the reason that the extended development of those four types of conscious awareness amplifies our already flawed belief that we are separate from the rest of creation. If there is a fifth degree of consciousness, it might be called a sense of Oneness. There is no evidence that anything else in creation is blind to its interconnectedness to the rest of creation, which forces me to question where human consciousness actually lies on creation’s consciousness continuum. In truth, the distinction is probably irrelevant.

The degree of consciousness that recognizes the interdependence of all species and all aspects of creation upon all others is a higher degree of consciousness because it understands that one’s efforts to respect and care for other life forms is the ultimate self-serving strategy. We cannot gain an advantage (for long) at the expense of others, whether it is the environment or an annoying neighbor.

This is the 15thin a series titled The Perplexities of Consciousness. Life Notes are my explorations into mysteries that interest me. They are invitations for readers to explore more deeply into life’s mysteries. Engage with me or explore contemplative spiritual direction at ghildenbrand@outlook.com.


[1] Michael Pollan, A World Appears, Penguin Press, New York, 2026, p. xxvi.


Discover more from Contemplating Grace

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply